This podcast is recorded in front of a live studio dog.
This is feelgoodery, where we vent, share the sore spots, laugh at the embarrassing, and occasionall talk about some really useful things taht can help us feel better if we’re in the mood. I’m Kyle Buchanan and today’s emphasis is on venttt. Because sometimes, better out than in. Second sparkle coming up, here we go.
Hello my friend - I hope you’re having a great day so far. My morning has been filled with procrastination, but like WORK procrastination. If you know what I mean. So I’m not playing video games or watching tv instead of working, I am sitting at my desk, at the working place, so your brain THINKS it’s doing sort of the right thing. But in reality, I’m just sitting at the computer, looking at the computer, going from tab to tab - not actually getting anything done.
If I have a random thought, I’ll google it. What was the thign I was goign to order on amazon? And I’ll go to amazon and then get sidetracked seeing something else, so then I research THAT product on a different tab, before going back to what I was supposed to be doing, but at this point - I have completely forgotten what I was supposed to do.
BUT I am AT my desk so it counts right.
I mean THESE are the most frustrating days. Where you feelin like you are SOMEWHAT working, you are in the position of doing work, your pouring your time into sitting and trying BUT NOTHING actually came from it.
It’s like sitting on the toilet struggling but NOTHING COMES OF IT. and you leave the washroom being “ well that was just a waste of my life wasn’t it.”
But you know what, even though work isn’t getting done as fast as I would like it, I am where I need to be. And I am TRYING.
It’s like putting your gym clothes on and going to the gym. Maybe the work out will suck, but you made the effort to get there.
Anyway, I think the reason I am procrastinating today, it that I was putting off slash DEBTING actually recording this episode.
But, as you can probably guess by now because you are listening to this thing I am recording . . . I DID decide to record this episode.
I’ve mentioned that I don’t love the nutrition and wellness industry before. And if you haevn’t heard me say that. Well, I’m saying it now. And I know I am part of it. And i get the irony. But I do have a love hate relationship with it.
Sometimes I think it can be a bit much, it can be overwhelming and annoying and SO friggin preachy. And on a frank personal level, a lot of the people hat are HUGE in the “wellness, nutrition, love yourself and be kind babe” are actually some of THE RUDEST PEOPLE in real life.I have encountered them myself and I have heard from very trusted first-hand accounts from some of my closest friends. And that gets me.
I also don’t love the extremes that come with it, and the judgements of other peoples work which I’ll get into in a bit. . But the truth is, balance and moderation aren’t NEWSY headlines. They’re not CLICK BAITY enough. And with the internet, for us to make a splash, we are put in this corner where we feel we have NO CHOICE but to be click baity and that FUELS the temptation to be judgemental against one another because that will get more views.
But where I do love the concept of it all, the concept of wellness - because at it’s core - the right nutrition and, and taking other steps that work for YOU and YOUR WELL BEING, it really can make a difference to how you go about your time on this planet. It can make it a more pleasurable, less-painful experience. And that’s why I’m still in this space, because I do believe it can make a solid difference.
But lately, I’ve been doing something that hasn’t been serving me, and has been sort of stoking the fire when it comes to my frustration of the nutrition and wellness industries . . .
I’ve been reading comments. On instagram, on facebook - for whatever reason, I have been glued to reading the comments on popular dietician pages, functional doctor pages, functional nutritionist pages and they VERY popular for no-credential reasons, wellness influencers.
Some of the posts are solid, some not so much, but it doesn’t matter how good or bad or accurate or inaccurate the information being shared is - the comments below are always teh same combination of things. It’s a mix of eye “eye roll” or “laughing” emojis belo w, followed by comments like “this is a scam, don’t waste your money” or “supplements are a hoax, you can get everything you need from diet” or “ THIS IS 100% FALSE” and on and on
And these comments were really getting to me. So I sat with it for a while. Why were these comments getting to me on such a deep level? Why was I getting so incredibly frustrated yet saddened by them?
And then I came across someone who is very reputable in my field on instragm, basically doing a story sharing about why another evidence-based expert was LYING to you, and why YOU should only listen to her evidence-based expert opinion and people who follow her methodology.
And then it all clicked. Pass the click-bait nature of what she was trying to do, I realized that what was getting to me most was not necessarily people that get ANGRY and their ARMS UP about the nutrition and wellness in industry as a whole, but the professionals IN THE NUTRITION & WELLNESS INDUSTRY ITSELF, and the divisiveness and righteousness within the industry.
The health and wellness world is filled with so much extremism, conflicting opinions, skewed evidence and dismissive experts that there is no room or space to tell what is what, or allow people to come up with their own unbiased conclusions for what might work for them.
And it creates frustration, overwhelm and a “what’s the point” mentality. So It’s no wonder we flock to the message boards to project our resentment.
So I want to make a few points and lay out some of my thoughts when it comes to the divisiveness in this industry.
First, When it comes to Nutrition . . .
It’s completely understandable why the subject of nutrition is so frustrating. It seems that what was terrible for you one year is now the food that will heal the world the next. And each year, a brand new diet comes about that will trump all the rest.
And adding to the daily news headlines, every now and then we have a documentary that comes out that truly gets the conversation going. These documentaries don't talk about moderation or balance, they tend to focus on the extremes, because that’s what gets the viewership numbers. There was one doc (that I won’t name) which came out a couple years ago that made the compelling argument everyone should become vegan to thrive. It had some points, but missed the mark in many other ways.
With documentaries, I highly encourage everyone to always look at who is producing them, and whether they might have a particular bias, or a conflict of interest (like perhaps, owning a vegan protein line and producing a vegan documentary . . . cough cough). But I digress.
When it comes to nutrition, and why some diets or eating methods work SO well for some, but make other people sick; the reason some thrive on going completely plant based, and others try and feel terrible. . .
The reason for all of these contradictions comes down to individuality. Each of us is a biological snowflake.We have different genetics, histories, environments, microbiomes, we have our own different traumas that live within us, we have different energetics depending on the day. Because of this, we will respond to things differently. What works for one will not necessarily work for another. This counts for so many interventions, including nutrition. What helps one person may make another person feel very sick.
It’s why you should do what is right for YOU, and be VERY weary of anyone who claims the way they eat is the ONLY way to eat, or YOU should avoid EVERYTHING they avoid.
Now listen I want to say -There are certain general practices that tend to do well for a lot of us - including getting enough protein, water, variety of produce and exercise. BUT . . . even then, you will find people that disagree with what I just said. The concept of eating more whole foods than ultraprocessed foods is another solid point.This stuff holds weight.
And I myself share foods that I tend to avoid and have recommended being avoided vs foods I would recommend, based on work I’ve done, and the education I have had. But what I always try to do is present it as an option to TRY ON FOR SIZE IF and only IF, you are working towards a health goal and you are looking for some information that might be of benefit to you.
And it isa very fine line. And If I’ve presented it ina way that seems judgemental, or absolute, then I apologize. But my PET PEEVE in this industry, in nutrition, is for those who CROSS THAT LINE. The expert who try to SCARE you or SHAME YOU into doing what they believe. Who throw SHADE at people who don’t believe what they do.
My goal is always to give information but to promote balance because LIFE IS SHORT - and STRESS will kill you faster than a gluten, sugar-filled desert every now and then.
Secondly, let’s talk about the science of nutrition
It’s a bit tricky when it comes to nutrition science as it’s a very difficult thing to study without outside variables having influence. A lot of nutritional studies are done using observational methods (i.e. observing a population and gather data) - but these tend to prove correlation and associations, not causation, when it comes to food. So X is associated with Y, X does not necessarily equal why.
One big issue with these observation studies is that they rely on self-reported data (things like food diaries and so on ) and they rely on people's memories to report what they eat, and let's face it, our memories can be quite unreliable. People may forget to mention certain foods or underestimate portion sizes, which can introduce errors into the data.
Another challenge is that our diets are incredibly complex. We don't just eat single nutrients or foods in isolation; we have a whole range of dietary habits that interact with each other. So, when a study finds a connection between a specific nutrient and health, it's tough to say whether it's that nutrient alone or a combination of factors driving the results.
There’s also something called "healthy user bias." This is an important point. People who participate in nutrition studies often already lead healthier lives. They might exercise more, avoid smoking, and generally make better lifestyle choices. So, when a study shows positive or negative outcomes for a specific diet or nutrient, it might not be solely due to those factors but could also be affected by the participants' overall healthier behaviors, and this can skew results.
If you are interested in this - I’d urge you to check out Chris Kresser, who talks about this a lot, especially in regards to backlash to red meat consumption. In terms of the healthy user biasis and the studies on red meat being bad for our health - He emphasizes that individuals who consciously reduce their red meat intake might also engage in other health-conscious behaviors. These individuals are more likely to consume whole foods, exercise regularly, and avoid harmful habits like smoking. Therefore, attributing health outcomes solely to reduced red meat consumption can be misleading, as these individuals have a range of healthier lifestyle factors at play. I’ll put that article in the show notes.
So when it comes to research, it’s a very complex and nuanced subject. There is room for error and we have to remember that. Headlines though, make it very hard to do this.
Moving on, I want to talk when it comes to different modalities, and different ways of healing.
Beyond nutrition, there are so many modalities to healing - acupuncture, naturopathic medicine, homeopathy, energetic medicine, reiki, therapy,
There are so many different ways in when it comes to healing. And depending on who you are, your route in might be different from someone elses. But that doesn’t mean their route is the wrong way, it’s just the route that works for them.
I believe that the more options to go around, the better. If we gave weight to some of the more natural alternatives, in the same way we give weight to more mainstream medicine. You can have both.
But it doesn’t help the cloud of confusion in this industry when experts in ONE field DISCOUNT someone else's field. (ie. a conventional doctor denouncing homeopathic medicine, OR on the other side, a naturopathic doctor DISCOUNTING the conventional medical system).
In my opinon, we should embrace the fact that we have so many people who have knowledge from varying fields and schools of thoughts, not shut them out or try to SHUT THEM DOWN, which seems to be happening more and more.
I truly think - if something has the potential to make someone feel better, there is merit to that. And if you don’t believe it does, then YOU DON”T HAVE TO DO IT. But don’t try to take away someone else’s right to try it for themselves. Or make them feel bad for exploring something that you don’t agree with.
When it comes to trusting a source (especially in the new world of influencer marketing nowadays), I trust someone who has schooling in their area of expertise, who continually learns and most importantly, is NOT adamant that their way is the ONLY way to do it, and not someone who easily dismisses another modality or opinion.
Just because we don’t understand something, doesn’t mean we dismiss it.
ONE RESPONSE TO A COMMON COMMENT
I do want to share my opinion about supplementing, because one comment that comes up a lot in all of these posts is that supplements are NOT necessary and you can get everything you need through diet. Here are my thoughts
YES, ideally get all of your nutrients from food. BUT, our soils aren’t as nutrient dense as they once were(https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/soil-depletion-and-nutrition-loss/), people tend to eat way fewer veggies than they should, tend to eat a very monotonous, processed diet which is vulnerable to nutrient deficiencies, and we have an increased need for nutrients with the more toxic and stressful environment humans find themselves in these days. Supplements can be a huge help to get you to the level of health you are striving for (i.e. thriving, not just surviving), or correct a deficiency faster. They are not meant to be forever (with some notable exceptions like Vitamin D) but at times when you need the extra help.
NOW - asterisk - Vitamins become a waste of money IF your digestion is suffering, and you aren’t actually absorbing the things you’re consuming (foods or vitamins), which is the bigger issue. This is why it is so important to nurture a healthy digestive system - and if you’re experiencing ongoing issues, consult a health care practitioner. And I will be getting into the nitty gritty of this later down the line on this podcast.
TODAYS FEEL GOOD THING
That sound means its time for today’s feelgood thing - which are day to day things that are worth a momentary spotlight so we can start training our brains to relish the little things more often, because it’s real easy for our brains to find the bad.
Today’s feel good thing is when you FINALLY get that damn ingrown hair. If you’ve never had an ingrown hair then I hope you had a kid so you can pass THAT magcial power on. But whether its on your face, on your leg or any of the MANY places we can have hair. Having a little naggy, painful hair that you just can’t get is ONE of the most frustrating things that can take up so much of your attention. Because it hurts, you know it’s growing in there and it somehow feels like its taunting you and your failed attempts to get it.
But then, that one glorious day happens when the tweezers or needle or whatever device you are using, when they get in at the righ angle and you pull that smug little hair right out. And you are FREE. To this day, I think about this one ingrown hair I had on my upper lip for months, it had grown into a little spiral and took a week of trying and a VERY inflamed looking upper lip as a result, BUT, the one day I did pull it out was one of the most satisfying days I have had. Anyways, getting that ingrown hair finally is todays feelgood thing.
CLOSING
Alright my friend, with that little ranty episode, we’ll close it out.
This industry can be exhausting, the wellness world can be annoying and there are days where I want to throw my phone out the window after seeing all the conflicting information and superior opinions out there.
I think part of the reason it frustrates me so much:
Is that people who might be kinder OR have a more neutral position are COACHED to BE more divisiff because that’s how you get followers and earn a living. We live in a world of click bait which unfortunately works, and helps people pay their bills. But beyond that - it just contributes to volatility and confusion for people who are just looking for ways to fell better.
At the end of the day, you have to do what’s right for you. There are endless ways for us to feelgood, and so many routes to get there. And we should be excited about that, what a wonderful world that we have so many doors are open to us. And my hope, is that those doors stay open, and aren’t shut because we forgot how to support one another when we disagree.
As always if you like this podcast, it would mean a lot to me if you take a second to give the show a 5 star rating, and /or little review because it does make an impact.
Here’s to doing what works for you. And here’s to trying. Even if it means, sitting at your computer, procrastinating, going from tab to tab and getting nothing done, but trying to set yourself up for succes nonethe less. End of rant. You have a wonderful day, and I will see you next time on feelgoodery.
The information provided in this podcast is for informational purposes only and is no a substitute for professional, medical advice. Please always consult with your health care provider.