We know that the nutrition world can be incredibly confusing, and frankly incredibly annoying. Part of the reason I do this podcast is to vent about my frustrations about the industry, because sometimes it really is exhausting to see all of the contradictory information out there and it can leave us feeling like there’s not even a point in trying. Which doesn’t serve us. And recently, a headline came out stating that intermittent fasting might be associated with an increased risk of cardiovascular death which is a very dramatic statement. So in today’s episode, I want us to eat a major grain of salt and let’s do a quick rundown on this headline. As always feelgoodery is recorded in front of a live studio dog. My name is Kyle Buchanan, I’m so happy you’re here because it means you’re putting in effort to help yourself feel good in some way. And I believe that when you feel good, more good comes. Here we go.
Goodness gracious this headline. I first heard this headline when a friend sent me the article asking “should we be concerned”, and as soon as I saw it- I did the biggest Liz Lemon Eye roll because I knew people would start thinking that they’re doing something dangerous for their health if they practice intermittent fasting.
And really when we think about this . . . when you start a new health regime, and you’re taking the steps and putting in the will power to adopt a new habit in the hopes of achieving a goal… that’s a big deal. And you should be proud of yourself for doing so.
Because when it comes to sustaining a new eating plan, in whatever way, a major component that isn’t talked about enough, is the energetic feeling your putting behind that goal. I work with a mind body gut philosophy, which works around the idea that it’s your thoughts, nervous system combined nutrition that can really effect lasting change and get you to that feel good place as quickly as possible.
So let’s say you’ve decided to trying intermittent fasting and you’re excited. The thought coudl be “I’m doing something really healthy for myself”. The feeling in the body - and this is always the tricker part - but the feeling in the body hopefully is a feeling of excitement and safety as yout start trying this out - and the gut aspect if the the beneficial biological processes that happen in the gut when you start fasting. It’s a one two three success. So you’re doing ALL THE THINGS HERE>
BUT THEN - a headline comes out like this. Saying that what you’ve been doing, that you’re excited about… MIGHT BE INCREASING YOUR RISK OF DEATH.
So what happens when we see that headline?
OUR MIND our thougths - goes to a place of concern
OUR BODY - and our nervous system stars to feel unsafe
And our GUT - most likely has that gut-drop feeling which just sends more signals to the brain that something is wrong.
IF this headline held weight, that’s one thing, and we do need to make adjustments with those, but this headline did not hold weight and jumped the gun.
AND added unnecessary drama.
So let’s get into it.
The headline that was forwarded to me stated Intermittent fasting linked to higher risk of cardiovascular death, research suggests.
And here’s the coles notes.
In March, at a conference early early early research was presented suggesting that people who eat all of their food within an 8 hour window may have a 91% increase in cardiovascular death.
And there are a lot of issues with this.
One, this has not been peer-reviewed or published yet, meaning other experts haven’t scrutinized it.
Two, this was an observational study, which means people had to recall what they ate and when, which is always tricky - and they only did that twice in the beginning of this 8 year observation - so they assumed that those 2 days would be indicative of a person's 8 years of eating.
And three, factors like what they were eating, how much they were eating and nutritional value weren’t considered. SO there are a lot of variables beyond timing worth considering. And it’s also worth noting that the people that were in the intermittent fasting category were not necessarily TRYING to intermittent fast, they just happened to eat within a shorter window. Some might have been, but others might just have been eating in that window for the two days that they remembered.
It’s just a matter of finding this pattern after looking at the numbers.
So there’s so much more to this.
But let’s play devils advocate, even though this is TOO early to really draw any concussions from . in trying to explain the results - researchers noted and offered an observation that one reason for this finding could be that those who had a shorter eating window had less lean muscle mass, and low lean muscle mass has been linked with a higher risk of cardiovascular death.
So maybe there are other factors at play… because we don’t know the nutritional status… I would offer a theory that maybe they weren’t consuming enough protein IN their eating window.
And I’ve talked about this before - intermittent fasting, a common misconception is that you can eat anything during your eating window and it won’t matter - but it’s crucailly important that you focus on WHAT you are eating, when you do it. AND a big factor is making sure you get enough protein in during your eating window, many of us don’t get enough. Getting enough protein helps support lean muscle mass, as well as resistance training especially as you get older. If that’s a major contributing factor to cardiovsaculr disease, these two things could help reduce that risk. So it is the timing persay, or is it the nutrional status of the day? This is where it can get a little tricky.
The other thing worth mentioning - is that with intermittent fasting, and I talked about this on the entire episode we did on it. With intermittent fasting, YOU DO NOT WANT TO OVER DO IT. You’re body likes variety.
Is it good to have you’re eating window withing a 8 hour period every day for 8 years? I would argue no. Fasting is a stressor on the body, albeit a good stressor when done right, but a stressor none the less. And it’s also worth noting that for some people, in the short term intermittent fasting can increase the stress load and bring up some things physiologically as the body adjusts, but the longer term benefit can be a beneficial one.
So in that case and from certain perspectives, this article MIGHT offer support for adding protein to your days, as well as NOT overdoing it when it comes to fasting. Both of which I do support.
So that’s all the other side. But largely, I think this is a VERY misleading headline. Because, in my opinion, I do think intermittent fasting can be a very useful, very effective tool. Especially when it comes to supporting digestive health and reducing systemic inflammation, as well as being a major support to brain health.
BUT it has to be done in the right way. And not overdone.
-
That sound means it’s time for today’s feelgood thing, which are the little things that deserve a spot in the momentary spotlight so we can train our brains to focus on the good because they are so damn good at focusing on the bad.
Today’s feelgood thing is on point today, it is the feeling of a long overdue, satisfying, dramatic - eye roll. If you’ve ever seen 30 rock I’m talking about a Liz Lemon style eye roll. Where you look up to the heavens out of annoyance while also saying “can you believe this my god”. Because sometimes things are SO ridiculous, that you have to let off some steam and roll your eyes to properly move on. It’s like an emotionless scream of relief. And also adds in just the right amount of humour. Both of which really can just help you feel just a little goooder.
-
Watch that after this episode a headline comes out saying that rolling your eyes is damaging your retinas. JUST wait.
If you enjoyed this episode, pleas feel free to share it on social media, text it to you friend who might find it useful. And also! If you haven’t yet, please press the subscribe button on this show’s page. It only takes the push of your finger, costs absolutely nothing but does help me and other people discover this show. Also new, if you want to stay in the loop with this show and other exciting things coming up on my end, including some exciting opportunities to work together, feel free to opt into my email list - and I’ll put that link in today’s shownotes.
It’s fair to say that this headline annoyed the crap out of me, because it majorly jumped the gun and just added to the confusion that YOU might already be feeling about how to eat to support you and your goals. We are already confused okay? We do not need one more thing.
And the other thing to remember, is that your thoughts, your energy, and how safe you feel in your body are incredibly important factors in your ability to feel good. We want to nurture them, and support them. And of utmost importance - we want to be careful and selective of WHAT WE LET IN. A headline can be a headline, but we have the power to choose whether the fear intended with that headline makes its way inside of us. Sometimes its best to give a headline it’s space, roll our eyes and continue on, knowing we’re doing things that we feel will truly help us feel good. I hope you have a wonderful day ahead. And I will see you next time on feelgoodery.
And now for the legal stuff. The information provided in this podcast is for informational purposes only, and is not a substitute for professional medical advice. Please always consult with your health care provider.